homeabout uscontact us
when you think real estate...

« Please release me | Main | GTA Realtors┬« Report Mid-February Resale Housing Market Figures »

CREA's Thoughts On Competition Bureau's Recent Actions

Much has been reported in the media about how the Competition Bureau has decided to bring a case to the Competition Tribunal alleging that the rules of The Canadian Real Estate Association (CREA) governing MLS® Systems are anti-competitive, restrict consumer choice and prevent innovation in the market for residential real estate. Let us be very clear: CREA’s rules are not anti-competitive, and CREA is confident that the Competition Tribunal will rule against the Commissioner of Competition following a hearing on the merits.

It is important when considering these issues to move beyond the sound bites and consider the facts: CREA currently has more than 98,000 members operating independently across the country, competing on a daily basis for the business of Canadian consumers. There are more consumer choices and more business models today than ever before - and that is a good thing. Consumers can negotiate the level of service they want and the fees or commission they will pay for that service.

What hasn’t changed – and cannot change to ensure the integrity of MLS® Systems which operate across the country - is the need for accurate and reliable information to be provided for use in MLS® Systems and a commitment by REALTORS® using MLS® Systems to comply with a code of ethics and regulatory requirements across the country. These basic requirements are necessary for the continued reliability of the MLS® System which Canadians have come to trust for years and years.

The fact that a home is listed on a real estate Board’s MLS® System provides an assurance to the public that the information regarding properties listed on Boards’ MLS® Systems is accurate and reliable and that there is professional involvement and accountability for that information - all of which protects the interests of homebuyers and sellers. This System provides consumers with not only choice, but also confidence, as they engage in one of the biggest and most important financial transactions of their lives.

The MLS® System is a cooperative marketing network established by REALTORS® several decades ago to help the public buy and sell real estate. MLS® Systems are member-to-member services, paid for by the REALTOR® members of a local Board or Association. It is the local real estate Board or Association that actually administers and operates each MLS® System across Canada. CREA owns the trademark and licenses its use to boards and associations. is simply an advertising website operated by CREA and competing with other websites on which properties are advertised by home sellers and REALTORS®. .

There have been numerous reports over the last several days that as a result of the Bureau’s actions commission rates will come down. The fact is that CREA’s rules have nothing to do with commission rates. CREA does not dictate or determine commission rates – or tell its members what business model to choose or how to run their businesses. The mythical “fixed commission rate” does not exist: any transaction between a REALTOR® and a home seller or buyer is subject to negotiation. In CREA’s view, consumer choice is a good thing and the market should decide.

CREA is proud of its members and the service they provide Canadians in a competitive environment. There should be no doubt that CREA’s ultimate interest and that of its members is to ensure that consumers continue to have choice and confidence in a vibrant, competitive market.

Dale Ripplinger
President, CREA

Posted on Thursday, February 18, 2010 at 06:32PM by Registered CommenterElaine in | Comments2 Comments

Reader Comments (2)

I am so happy to know that the CREA is fighting and not rolling over to the false accusations of this Commissioner of the Competition bureau,who has appointed herself the "Commissioner of realestate."There is nothing but competiton in the CREA with varying listing commissions from a few hundred dollars to thousands of dollars.If a Realtor chooses to be a Discount Realtor,there is absolutely nothing wrong with that.However that does not excuse that REaltor or any other realtor from having a fudiciary duty to the seller and properly represent and protect him in a realestate transaction.What's this Commissioner of Competition bureau's problem? She doesn't care that we already are very competitive,she wants to go beyond her field of expertise into the field of realestate which she has very limited knowledge in and re-write the "laws of Agency"preaching that sellers don't need representation or protection in a realestate transaction. That this is a viable and safe,money saving option.Since when is it her place to be a "Realestate Expert" and to take away our "rights of Ownership" of the MLS system which we own and pay for and cancel our seller representative services (as an option) in which we make our livlihood with?It's about as ridiculous as taking over a cab driver's vehicle and cancelling out his driving service allowing passengers to drive themselves so they don't have to pay as much. Then when the cab driver refuses he's told by the Government he is anti-competitive and limiting choices to the consumer. Well the MLS system is our vehicle which we both own and pay for.This commissioner has absolutely no right to steal our vehicle,cancel out our services(as an option) and give our vehicle(MLS)away to "Do it yourself Sellers". Just as a FSBO has the right to do what he wants with the home that he owns having the full bundle of rights.Does not the CREA and it's Realtor members also have the "right of Ownership" and the full bundle of rights to do what they want with what they own and pay for,which is the MLS system? Just as the taxi cab and it's driver service is inseparable likewise the MLS system which is our vehicle and our realestate service must also be inseparable.
February 24, 2010 | Unregistered CommenterBill Lafferty
There are realtors out there that are worth what they charge for commission. This new rule will hopefully weed out the bad ones who just list on MLS and call it a day. It will definitely force many realtors to reconsider how they do business.

PostPost a New Comment

Enter your information below to add a new comment.

My response is on my own website »
Author Email (optional):
Author URL (optional):
All HTML will be escaped. Hyperlinks will be created for URLs automatically.